7-year-old niece throws a tantrum because her aunt won't let her hold her 6-month-old baby: 'My niece forgets that I was the original mean little girl.'

Advertisement
  • A woman holding a baby in her arms
  • Am I the bad guy for calling my 7-year-old niece mean and enraging my sister-in-law?

    This happened a couple weeks ago and I can't stop thinking about it / wondering if I was in the wrong.
  • I (34F) was out to an early dinner with my entire family to celebrate my mom's birthday. We brought my daughter (6m) with us and I was holding her sitting next to my mom.
  • My niece is a bit entitled / is never really told no. When we first sat down she threw a fit that she wasn't allowed to sit next to my daughter but given that it was literally my
  • mom's birthday, I ignored it. My brother (38M) and SIL (35F) handled it by saying she could just stand between us as much as she wanted to be by the baby.
  • I ended up letting my mom hold my baby a bunch at her request and my niece, who was sitting on the other side of her, basically was laying on top of her petting my daughter holding her hand etc. it was fine.
  • Dinner took significantly longer than I anticipated so it was nearing my daughter's bedtime and she was starting to get a little fussy. I changed her and had her a bottle but she was still a little whiny and extra wiggly, you know how babies can be.
  • I was mostly holding her so that if she got loud I could take her out of the restaurant. By this time my niece had kicked my mom out of her seat when my mom got up to
  • use the bathroom and she took it to sit next to my daughter. My mom was mildly annoyed but let it go.
  • At this point my mom was now holding my daughter again because she loves soaking up as many baby snuggles as possible. My niece told her she wanted to hold the baby. My
  • mom said she had to ask me. My niece didn't like that because she doesn't like when she doesn't immediately get her way. She gave her a dirty look but turned toward me.
  • Grayscale photo of a girls face
  • My niece asked if she could hold my daughter "by herself" and I said no because she was fussy and kept throwing her head back and given we were at a table and my niece is small herself I wasn't comfortable with that.
  • My niece is not used to hearing the word no so she gave me a dirty look and stormed off. I knew what was happening. She was going to tell on me for "being mean". I
  • watched her walk over to my brother and tell him I was being mean and when he asked why she didn't give him a reason. Instead she waited and then told him she wanted to hold my daughter.
  • My brother, not knowing any of the things that went down, asked my mom who was holding her if he could hold the baby. My mom didn't
  • realize that my niece had gone to him so she hands him my daughter and the looks at me as she watches him start to hand my daughter over to my niece.
  • I almost let her just hold the baby. But right as he was about to put her on my niece's lap she looked up at me and gave me this "look I got my way" smirk and I changed my mind. I stop my brother.
  • He said oh is she not allowed to hold her right now? And I said not by herself. Well all h..l broke loose. My niece lost it. Crying.
  • Throwing a temper tantrum. Turning to her mom who I could hear say she would let her hold. the baby in a moment. I doubled down. I said absolutely not. She could hold her but not by herself. It got so bad they
  • basically had to take my niece outside. After my SIL and niece left the table, my brother said he didn't think my baby was the fussy / wiggly and that my niece probably would have been fine to hold her. I
  • told him I probably would have let her if she hadn't given me that smirk and tried to go behind my back to her way.
  • Then I said "niece forgets that I was the original mean little girl, so her tactics aren't going to work on me" he didn't seem to love that comment. I stand by it.
  • A little girl sitting on a couch looking at the camera
  • When she doesn't get her way she's mean as heck. And when it comes to what I say regarding my own daughter I definitely won't be backing down.
  • My brother said my SIL heard the comment and was pretty irritated by it because calling niece mean was "uncalled for" and I could have just let her hold the baby.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article